Transcript for Michael Perry on Being a Wisconsin Writer

Jim Fleming: Ever ride a bus or a train and notice everybody’s reading the same three or four books?  It’s a phenomenon that drives Charles McNair crazy.  He’s the Books Editor at Paste Magazine, and an avowed champion of Southern Literary Voice.  McNair told Anne Strainchamps that a handful of opinions from critics out of New York and L.A. carry too much weight and keep unknown voices from rising to the top. 



Charles McNair: Well, let me give you an example of two writers that I believe would be celebrated internationally if they didn’t live where they happen to live.  Both of these live in Arkansas, which is not renowned as a center of cultural taste making, unless you like Wal-Mart.  I would say that these two writers, one is named Donald Harrington, and the other is named Charles Portis.  Both have written a number of books.  I’d say of the two, the better known is Charles Portis.  He wrote True Grit, and he wrote a great book called Norwood.  These are central figures in American writing today, in my opinion.  There’s another writer, Kevin Brochmeier.  He is younger, he is more celebrated.  He also is living, I believe, now in Arkansas and from Arkansas, so we have these three names who I believe, had they been west coast names, anywhere around Hollywood, or on the east coast, anywhere around that great pulsar of communication, the New York scene, would be widely celebrated, and as famous as Norman Mailer or let’s say from the west coast, Joan Didion. 



Anne Strainchamps: Now why is that, do you think, because I would imagine if we were to call Lev Grossman, say, the book editor at Time Magazine, or John Thurber at the L.A. Times, or Michiko Kakutani at the New York times, they would say not only do they not care where a writer lives, often they don’t even know. 



McNair: I’d say that’s true.  Certainly for Lev, he’s a friend of mine.  I’ve known him for a few years.  He’s also a darn good writer himself, so naturally he’s going to know what good writing is.  I think that in this case, Marshall McCluhan was right, the medium is the message.  It’s where they write, it’s the megaphones they have that matter more than anything else.  If you are in New York and you are writing for Time Magazine or The New York Times, or The New Yorker, you have, for better or worse, an opinion that seems to matter more than the opinion from Atlanta, Georgia, or from Moscow, Idaho.  There are a hundred million people who live in the south.  Why isn’t it so that some cultural voice here matters everywhere else, the way The New York Times matters, or the way the L.A. Times matters out there?  I have a number of theories about this and probably none of them account for it wholly.



Anne Strainchamps: Well, what are some of your theories?



McNair: For one thing, the south hasn’t helped itself much by being as ornery as it has proven to be through the past several centuries.  You start out with a losing nation, the south lost the Civil War, and hence you retire to the loser’s corner and you sit and you brood for a hundred years, and out of that there did leap some voices and some folks got noticed over years, but in the main it was, as H. L. Mencken pronounced it, ‘the Sahara of the Bozart.’  Now that is an attitude that took hold and rightly or wrongly, there is a stereotype about that.  I remember a Lenny Bruce line from the Lenny Bruce years of the 1960's.  He was making a to-do about how the southern accent is the least respected accent in any speaking idiom anywhere, and he made the point by saying, ‘if Albert Einstein had talked like this, there wouldn’t be no bomb.’  That is a quote from Lenny Bruce.  Now there is great truth in that.



Anne Strainchamps: On the other hand, there are entire college classes taught on the great southern writers.  We produced this show out of the mid-west.  I’m pretty sure there aren’t any college classes on great middle western writers.



McNair: Well, there should be, and I would say that I’m not only arguing this case for the southern, the hundred million people in the south, although I’m from Alabama and a deep southerner, but also for these other propenquities that ought to have a cultural voice that people listen to, that people harken to.



Anne Strainchamps: It’s interesting that one theory that you didn’t mention would have to do with money.  I mean a huge pile of the nation’s money is centered in New York and another huge pile in Los Angeles.  Those are simply the places where, if you want to start a national newspaper or a national arts magazine, that’s where the money is and that’s where you start it.  Surely that’s part of the picture?



McNair: I don’t think that that’s wrong in any way.  I don’t think, though, that if one is an artist, that one would accept that that has to be the way that people get attention.  I’m the Books Editor at a little magazine that popped up out of nowhere in Decatur, Georgia.  It’s called Paste Magazine, and when we were a paper publication, we were finalists for four years in a row in general excellence for the National Magazine Award.  It’s like the Oscar of the magazine world.  We were nosed out one year by National Geographic, one year by New York Magazine, so a very fine magazine.  We have evolved due to necessity and probably smartness, to on-line only now and Paste is making money.  We position ourselves as being signs of life in culture and we hoped that this publication somehow or another would become an influencer, a place where people came as a destination to hear not what New York thought, not what L.A. thought, but culture with a southern accent.  What did people think who lived down here, this hundred million folks.  You know, we have a lot more in common with this voice here than we do with the voice in New York and the voice in California, and you would say the same for the people in the mid-west.  They should have something there.  The tragedy is, you talk about the money, I look around this landscape here.  There is not one single newspaper that speaks with a regional voice anymore. 



Anne Strainchamps: The internet, of course, is springing up and lots of people can publish there and find a readership.  Do you possibly see a kind of new renaissance of regional writing, regional culture because of the internet?



McNair: Well, again this is almost at odds with the idea of celebrity in a way.  You can be a hometown hero easier now through the internet.  The question is, how do you jump over the barricade of the hometown and into the larger picture?  I think that’s not easier than it used to be.  I think that rather than being the great democratizer, what the internet has become and offered us is the great segmenter.  It allows people who believe one thing, to burrow ever deeper into that one single thing that they believe, at the expense of seeing and running and colliding into other ideas, and other influences, so I am not sure that the internet is the answer to this question of parochiality and this question of local versus national attention getting.



Anne Strainchamps: Well, I‘m curious, in 2011 you wrote a review of a time travel novel called The Revisionist, and you said it was a really, really good novel, maybe great, but you pointed out that it had the bad luck to come out about the same time as Stephen King’s last book, which was also about time travel.  The result was, King’s book got reviewed, The Revisionist didn’t.  Did the fact that you pointed that out in print make a difference, do you think?



McNair: Well, it made a difference to me and to that writer.  At least there was my little megaphone and my little voice saying to this great wide world, a thing that ought to have been said about that book.  I think that Tom Mullen, that writer who wrote The Revisionist, is going to be a very big writer if and when that stardust ever falls on him.  It depends on others.  It’s terrible to think that it depends on others, that it can’t happen just by dent of your own talent and your own skill, but it has always been that way, and we go on about Hollywood, but nothing is more  true than that good luck accounts for very much out there and it’s likely true in New York.  Good luck accounts for a lot of things, not just the skill and I believe that I would probably be right in saying that there are writers in Brooklyn and in Queens and in downtown Manhattan who are having the same lament that we are discussing here, that somehow or another, the powers that be swing those arc lamps across the heavens in other directions, not on them, and what’s to be done. I’d love to remedy that.



Jim Fleming: Charles McNair is a Pulitzer Prize nominated author and the Books Editor at Paste Magazine.  He lives in Atlanta, Georgia.  Anne Strainchamps spoke with him.

Comments for this interview

Michael Perry (Diane in Wisconsin, 03/12/2012 - 11:08am)

The best. He and his books brighten any day.

Michael Perry interview (Beverly, 03/11/2012 - 2:10pm)

Nice! Alway good to hear Michael's voice. Thanks for providing this.


great put up, very informative. I wonder why the other experts of this sector do not understand this. You should continue your writing. I am confident, you have a huge readers' base already!
heren uggs online bestellen

I am regular visitor, how are you everybody? This paragraph posted at this web site is really pleasant.
ugg boots outlet new york

Liu Ming eyes fell on that figure, the heart of a dynamic, does this represent this is the seventh-ninth day the door of the General Assembly mean?
Canada Goose Jacket vente

Liu Ming, although far more than the spiritual power of the same order of monks, but the spirit of this stock under pressure, but also in a while drowsy brain intuition and quickly pushed the knowledge of insects, this is not as near as a few people over there unbearable.
moncler femme pas cher

Today, I went to the beachfront with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave it to my 4 year old daughter and said "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She put the shell to her ear and screamed. There was a hermit crab inside and it pinched her ear. She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is completely off topic but I had to tell someone!
[url=]ugg italia milano[/url]

celine luggage bag replica <a href=" The Following Internet Site</a>
[url= Quality Celine Replica[/url]

Wow, wonderful weblog structure! How long have you been blogging for? you made running a blog glance easy. The overall glance of your site is great, as smartly as the content
moncler baby jas outlet

"Do not misunderstand fellow, in that case, the day the door will then coupled with the two of them now." Tianhe old man thought for a moment, finally did some grudging nod point.
giubbini moncler

But the heads of the four Taizong, eight family, such as super-large valley demon days, such as Ge, who live day, but already look pale, face extremely ugly.
Piumini moncler uomo

ハンドメイド 手縫い バッグ
サラリーマン 靴 寿命
礼装 バッグ 男性
celine セリーヌ  本物と偽物違い
化粧品 ブランド バイト!-supplement.html
バーバリー コットンマフラー
air jordan 3lab5 偽物
財布 男 通販
ネックレス 錆びの取り方
ヴィトン バッグ コピー

ニューエラかぶり方 女
オレンジ ネイルシャツ
ダコタ バッグ 直営店
靴下屋 アルバイト
クロムハーツ ペンダントトップ
100均 子供 ベルト
母子手帳ケース バーバリー
ヨドバシカメラ カルチェ タンクアメリカン
プラダ ネオプレーン トート
男性 スーツ 蝶ネクタイ きこなし

クロエ マフラー 値段
ゴールド 指輪 重さ
jo malone 香水 博客
ヴィトン ボディバッグ 激安
ポールスミス 小銭入れ メンズ
財布 おすすめ 8月
ディオールオム ダッフルバッグ買取
コーチ バッグ 77378
パロディ シャネル ステッカー
ゴールドネックレス メンズ
ピンキー ダイアン 財布 通販
ジミーチュウ 小銭入れ
通勤 バッグ 斜めがけ

無印 手作りトートバッグ
財布 プラダ 芸能人
奈良県 ネクタイ 安い
カルティエ 指輪2連
レザー クラフト リメイク 豊橋
姫川 バッグ 赤
プラダ カナパパロディ
ルイヴィトン vic
バッグインバッグ eyeco
バーバリー 財布 格安
革 バッグ 手入れ セット
ディオール 新作コート
ピアジェ 指輪 芸能人
クロエ クリスマス リング
バッグ 容量 計算 ah

adidas ジャージ  青  黄ストライプ
財布 メンズ ブランド 大学生
tifferny 鑵曟檪瑷堛儥銉儓銇氦鎻涘彲鑳?
ゴローズ メタル 小
バーバリー ダッフルコート チルドレン
ベルト メンズ おすすめ 映画

オークリー jawbone 交換レンズ
フルラ バッグ ホワイト
手作り 財布 型紙 無料
クロエ マーシー キーケース
ケイトスペード バッグ 名古屋
ベルト ファッション 30代
ゴローズ バングル サイズ
セリーヌ ブレスレット ダイヤモンド
女性 着こなし バーバリー ステンカラー コート
博多 大丸 ルブタン
loopwheeler スニーカー予約
ミュウミュウ 風 財布
シャネル 2015 ギャランティー
財布 縁起 日
ブルガリ トンド 桜 新品
指輪 8号 サイズ
バッグ メンズ 中学生

This article will assist the internet visitors for setting up new weblog or even a weblog from start to end.
peuterey uomo estate 2012

化粧品 優待 おすすめ
ミニクリスチャンディオール 香水 人気
timberland 金沢ショップ
銀のスプーン エルメス
御殿場アウトレット プラダ ダウン
ジョーダン true flight ひも
il bisonte 財布 オレンジ
化粧品 薬事 求人 東京
コーチ ボストンバッグ メンズ
財布 メンズ mcm
ミュウミュウ バック 広島
大きいサイズ 靴 レディース オリエンタル
gucciキッズ 豚フェイス

電池交換 カルティエ タンク
ワイルドスワンズ 財布
シャネル フラットシューズ メンズ
north face 財布
おしゃれな ニューバランス
アクセサリー ゴローズ
小物ケース プラスチック 引き出し
サマンサタバサ 財布 可愛い
ゴヤール コピー
財布 おすすめ レディース 30代
bvlgari 新作 リング
クロエ 財布 lily 新作
おしゃれ バッグ 激安
セリーヌ キャンバスショルダーバッグ

ルイヴィトン ファー バッグ
wego iphoneケース 外し方
バーバリー チーク
ポールスミス コインケース
セリーヌ デニム バッグ
バッグ 通販 world
ポールスミス スニーカー
トリーバーチ 財布 切手 通販
池袋 ライター 修理
ケイトスペード 50代
背景 画像 化粧品
zippo グッチ
バッグ クリーニング 自分で
ナイキ エアマックス90 キッズ
ルイヴィトン 財布 クリーニング

アディダス 時計 紫
ブルガリ 銀座三越
anna sui 財布 20代
ポールスミス ミニ 財布
ブランド ネクタイ 大阪市
dior addict to life eaude toilette廃盤
ベルト 修理 吉祥寺
大黒屋 ケイトスペード
真珠 指輪 どの指
トリーバーチ風 リュック
goyard ゴヤール サンルイ トートバッグ

ミュウミュウ カバン 旧作
財布 クロエ 安い
楽天 化粧品 美容液
バッグ がま口 大きい
rady コピー
ヴィトン 布団
財布 拾った 連絡
ケイトスペード マザーズバッグ 2way
財布 ブランド 女性 人気
指輪 ジュピター wikipedia
クロムハーツ 家具
財布 おすすめ メンズ
ルブタン アンクルブーツ レディース
ワンショルダーバッグ 作り方
プラダ 色展開

トリーバーチ サングラス 偽物
ファーチャーム 人気 ピコタン
adidas iphoneカバー ゴールド
メガネケース ブランド フェンディ
セリーヌ スマホカバー
グッチ 時計 ピンク ダイヤ
ルブタン 財布 中古
ディオール 新作 香水
ブルガリ メガネ 店舗
ポールスミス ファイナルアイズ
バッグ 持ち手 芯 修理
ガムテープ 小物入れ 作り方
化粧品 試供品 月額

I obtained these cheap wow gold as being a reward last year and fell in adore with them! it absolutely was so adorable! liked them!

革靴 ワックス おすすめ メンズ
クロエ トートバッグ パッツィー
ベルト 中国語 翻訳
トリーバーチ zip tote 取扱店
オークリー ゴルフ レディースウェア
プラダ キャンディーフローラレ 販売場所
ゴヤール 財布 二つ折り
ダンク パーカー
ヴィトン 財布 緑 柄
名古屋市 ダウンジャケット 大須
革靴 選び方 2014

クリスチャンルブタン セール 4プラ
paul smith セール
財布 30代 レディース
ネクタイ フォーマル ブランド
クロムハーツ クロスボールネックレス

ベルト メンズ ごつい
miumiu 公式 東京


Add new comment

Plain text

  • No HTML tags allowed.
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Lines and paragraphs break automatically.